Two Little Red Hens (2nd ave at 86th)

The cookies at Two Little Red Hens are phenomenal (I had the chocolate crinkle). The scone I had was pretty good too, but I really needed coffee with it. I'm dying to try the cakes or cupcakes there - when I went there were a bunch of families picking up cakes for various occasions. It's an adorable tiny location with a few tables, and it's almost always crowded - a very good sign!